LIVE

SIGI

Selective Insurance Group, Inc.

SIGI

NASDAQ·Financial Services·Insurance - Property & Casualty·Mkt cap $5.9B

$100.15

+2.17%

View full research view

Our plain-language verdict, the thesis, risk factors, and what is changing about the business.

View research view

52-Week Range

$71.75 - $100.30

P/E

13.70

Fwd P/E

12.87

Beta

0.31

Div Yield

1.70%

Avg Vol

586.9K

Shares Out

59.9M

Mkt Cap

$5.9B

Price action

Price chart

Up 15.2% over the trailing year

1W
1M
3M
6M
YTD
1Y
5Y
MAX

Total returns

Price performance

Total return across standard periods - splits & dividends adjusted by FMP. Periods longer than 1Y show annualized in the tooltip.

Why we rate it this way

The thesis at a glance

Bull and bear case · plain-English context across the five lenses we evaluate.

Bull Case

5 reasons

  • Century-long operating history and brand recognition since 1926
  • Disciplined underwriting culture focused on profitability over volume
  • Diversified distribution network through independent and wholesale agents
  • Multi-segment portfolio reducing dependence on single market or product line
  • Strong investment portfolio management generating supplementary returns

Bear Case

1 risk

  • Low volatility (beta 0.3).

Growth

Mild headwinds expected

Premium growth through expanded agent relationships and market penetration

Value

Fairly valued vs Property & Casualty Insurance peers

Momentum

Hot

+27.4% over 3m

Quality

Strong

Excellent business quality

Dividend

Modest

1.70% yield

Earnings track record

Recent earnings results

AI-summarized recap of last quarter, plus the surprise on every print.

Next: Apr 21, 2026

Q2 26 RECAP

APR 22, 2026

Reported EPS of $1.69 vs $1.80 consensus (-6.1% surprise). Revenue of $1.2B vs $1.3B expected (-5.1%).

EPS miss
Revenue miss

EPS surprise · last 4Q

0 of 1 beats

Q2 26

-6.1%

Next: Apr 21, 2026

Revenue trend · last 8Q

+13%

+10%

+10%

+9%

+9%

+5%

Q2 24

Q3 24

Q4 24

Q1 25

Q2 25

Q3 25

Q4 25

Q1 26

$1.2B

$1.2B

$1.2B

$1.3B

$1.3B

$1.4B

$1.4B

$1.4B

Margins · last 8Q

Gross

39.7%

Operating

9.2%

Profit

7.2%

Wall Street consensus

5 analysts · 60% Buy

Live ratings and price targets aggregated across covering analysts.

Buy

3

60%

Hold

2

40%

Sell

0%

Median Price Target

$95.00

-5.1% vs $100.15

Low $93.00
Median $95.00
High $97.00

Latest: Piper Sandler · $93.00 · May 26, 2026

2 analysts covering

vs Industry

How SIGI stacks vs Insurance - Property & Casualty

Stock metrics vs industry averages. Green = better than industry.

Industry comparison data unavailable for this stock.